Skip to main content
HomePizzaMenuHistory and MissionMeet the OwnerContact

This is the season of new life, of blossoming, of growth! Whether you are looking forward to Easter, or Passover, or are just someone who lives in awareness of the changing season, one cannot help but be moved by the amazing array of colors and smells that come with the Spring season. At Tyler's Pizzeria and Bakery, we are no match for Mother Nature and her grand array, but we too provide a delicious assortment of tasty treats and savory dinners that also come with great smells and colors! Be sure to check out our Lenten Special and our Holiday menu (shown below in yellow) for the upcoming Easter and Passover weekend, and get your orders in as soon as possible.


Apple with crumb topping (10.95)

Pecan (11.95)

Dinner Rolls (half/dozen)

Sweet Rustic (2.50/5.00)

Challah Knots (3.00/6.00)

Plain Crossaints (1.75ea/9.50hd)

Specialty Breads and Dinner Rolls

Hot Cross Buns (7.00 half dozen)

Easter Bunny Bread: Sweet Rustic 7.75/Challah 8.75

Carrot Cake with Cream Cheese Icing (7.95)

Poppy Seed Walnut (5.95)


Sweet Rustic (5.00)

Challah (6.00)

Honey Whole Wheat (5.00)

Cookies ($5 half dozen)

­­­Iced (or not) Easter Sugar Cookies


Chocolate Chip

Oatmeal Cranberry

Butter Cream Icing Easter Brownies (4-pak)

Special Sweets and Savories

Blueberry Choc. Chip Bars (1.25 ea./6.50 half)

Lemon Delight Croissants (2.50 ea./13.50 half)

Cinnamon Croissants (2.00 ea./11.00 half)

Chocolate Croissants (2.00 ea./11.00 half)

Mixed Berry Scones (2.00 ea/11.00 half)

Buttery Cranberry Scones (2.00 ea/11.00 half)
Spinach & Feta Croissants (4.00)

Ham & Cheese Croissants (4.00)

Hours: Tues.- Fri.: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Sat.: 9:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Pizza Making starts each day at 2:00 PM

Closed Sunday and Monday

Lenten Special
$1.00 off of Veggie Pizzas every Friday

Seasonal Specialty Pizzas
Irish Eyes Are Smiling 
Pauper's Pie
Potato Foccacia
Three Cheese Pizza: Hand Shredded Mozz./Cheddar/Fresh Mozz.

Gaelic Garlic
California Chicken


Click on the Pizza tab for our complete offerings

Our pizza is baked in our wood burning stone oven. 

Our baked goods are made from scratch and baked fresh every day.

Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery Mailing List
We invite you to join our mailing list to receive updates information throughout the year. Your information is safe with us and we will only use it to send you information about the Tylers Pizzeria and Bakery.

Email Address

Email list signup

Site Mailing List 
Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery - home of the wood fired oven! Open Tuesday through Friday, 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM; Saturday, 9:00 AM - 9:00 PM. Pizza making begins around 2:00 PM each day.

Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery
7516 East Main Street, Reynoldsburg, OH  43068   614-322-9587
Email: use
contact form 

Site designed and managed by Assist By Evans.

Create your own website
WebStudio Website Builder